After a car accident, one of the most important pieces of documentation is the police report. Insurance companies and attorneys often rely on this report to determine fault, assess damage, and settle claims. But what happens if the police report is wrong—and that mistake could cost you compensation or affect your legal standing? “How to Dispute a Wrong Police Report After a Car Accident”
The good news is that you can dispute a police report, but it requires prompt action, clear documentation, and the right strategy.
In this guide, you’ll learn:
What’s in a police report and why it matters
Common errors that appear in accident reports
How to correct factual mistakes or challenge opinions
When and how to involve legal help
Have questions about your accident report? Don’t go it alone.
📢 Get a Free Case Evaluation Now 📢
What Is a Police Report in a Car Accident Case?
A police report is an official document created by the responding officer after a motor vehicle accident. It typically includes:
The time, date, and location of the crash
Descriptions of the vehicles and damage
Names and statements of involved parties and witnesses
Diagrams or sketches of the accident scene
The officer’s observations and opinions
Traffic citations issued (if any)
🚨 Why It Matters: Insurance companies use the police report to help decide who was at fault and how much to pay in a settlement. Errors in this document can lead to denied claims, reduced compensation, or unjust blame.
Common Errors in Police Reports
Not all mistakes are malicious—officers work quickly under pressure and sometimes get things wrong.
Here are some of the most common police report errors:
✅ Factual Errors
- Misspelled names
- Incorrect vehicle information
- Wrong insurance details
- Inaccurate time or date
- Misstated location of the accident
🚨 Disputed Statements or Quotes
- The officer may misinterpret or misquote what you said.
- The other party may lie or provide false details that go unchallenged.
⚠️ Incorrect Diagrams
- A diagram might place your vehicle in the wrong position or direction.
❌ Fault Assignment or Officer Opinion
- Police officers often include their personal judgment about who caused the accident—this is not always correct or based on full evidence.
📢 Was the Police Report Used to Deny Your Claim? Talk to a Lawyer 📢
How to Dispute a Wrong Police Report
✅ Step 1: Obtain a Copy of the Report
You’ll need the full report to identify and address the errors. You can request it:
✔ From the responding police department
✔ Through your insurance company
💡 TIP: Don’t rely on memory—read the entire report line by line.
✅ Step 2: Identify and Document the Errors
Make a list of each mistake and collect supporting evidence to back up your version. This could include:
Photos of the accident scene
Dashcam footage
Witness statements
Your own written statement taken immediately after the accident
📸 Visual evidence is especially powerful when disputing diagrams or vehicle positions.
✅ Step 3: Contact the Reporting Officer
Reach out politely to the officer who filed the report. Ask:
If they’re willing to correct factual errors
What their process is for submitting a correction or supplement
If you can add a written statement to the report
🚨 NOTE: Officers are more likely to correct factual errors than subjective opinions.
✅ Step 4: Submit a Written Dispute with Evidence
If the officer is unwilling or unable to amend the report, write a formal dispute:
Address it to the police department’s records division or internal affairs
Clearly list each disputed item
Attach all supporting documents (photos, videos, statements)
Keep a copy for your records
📢 Need Help Writing a Formal Dispute? We Can Assist 📢
✅ Step 5: Include a Statement in the Report (If Allowed)
Some police departments allow drivers to submit an addendum or supplemental statement to the report.
✔ This won’t erase the original content, but it will ensure your version of the events is documented.
✔ It may be enough to raise doubt and help your case during an insurance investigation.
Can You Change the Officer’s Opinion on Fault?
This is the hardest type of error to challenge. While factual inaccuracies are easier to fix, getting an officer to reverse their opinion about fault is rare.
However, you can still dispute it through your attorney or insurance company, especially if you have:
Dashcam footage contradicting the officer’s view
Witnesses who confirm your side
Physical evidence like brake marks or traffic camera video
🚨 REMEMBER: The officer’s opinion on fault is not legally binding—insurance adjusters and courts make their own decisions.
📢 Disagree with the Fault Assignment? Get Legal Help Today 📢
How Incorrect Police Reports Impact Your Insurance Claim
Insurance companies often treat the police report as strong evidence, even though it may not tell the full story.
If the report favors the other driver:
Your claim may be denied or undervalued
Your insurance premiums may increase
You could be assigned blame for an accident you didn’t cause
By disputing errors early, you can strengthen your case and protect your rights.
When Should You Talk to a Lawyer?
You should consult a lawyer if:
The report wrongly blames you for the accident
You’re facing denied claims or reduced compensation
You were injured and the report could hurt your personal injury case
The police department refuses to correct clear errors
📢 Let a Professional Review Your Case for Free 📢
Final Thoughts: Fixing a Wrong Police Report Can Protect Your Future
🚗 Key Takeaways:
Police reports are important but not infallible.
Mistakes in the report can hurt your case or reduce your payout.
You can dispute the report with evidence, a written statement, or legal help.
The sooner you act, the better your chances of a correction.
A wrong police report doesn’t have to define your case—you have the right to fight back and correct the record.
📢 Get a Free Case Evaluation and Protect Your Rights 📢
“How to Dispute a Wrong Police Report After a Car Accident”
