After a car accident, one of the first phone calls you’ll receive may be from an insurance adjuster. While they may sound friendly and helpful, it’s important to remember that they work for the insurance company—not for you. Their job is to limit the amount of money paid out on your claim, even if that means using your own words against you. “What Not to Say to an Insurance Adjuster After a Car Accident”
That’s why knowing what not to say to an insurance adjuster after a car accident is critical. A simple statement made without thinking can seriously harm your chances of receiving fair compensation.
In this post, we’ll cover:
Why your words matter so much
The top 5 things you should never say
Tips on how to protect your legal rights after an accident
Need help dealing with an insurance adjuster?
📢 Get a Free Case Evaluation Here 📢
Why You Need to Be Careful Talking to an Insurance Adjuster
After an accident, emotions run high and details can be fuzzy. Insurance adjusters take advantage of this vulnerability by asking questions that may seem routine but are designed to elicit statements that can be used to deny or reduce your claim.
Anything you say could be:
Taken out of context
Used to assign fault
Misinterpreted as admitting guilt
Used to question the severity of your injuries
Even a simple apology or estimate of damage can come back to haunt you.
The Top 5 Things You Should Never Say to an Insurance Adjuster
1. “I’m Sorry” or “It Was My Fault”
While it’s natural to feel sympathy or want to be polite after an accident, never admit fault—even partially. You may not have all the facts or understand all the circumstances yet.
Why this is a problem:
✔ Admitting fault can limit your ability to collect damages, even if the other driver was mostly responsible.
✔ Fault is often determined by police reports, traffic laws, and accident reconstructions—not your initial statement.
✅ What to say instead: “I’m still processing what happened. I’d like to speak with my attorney before giving any statements.”
📢 Accused of Fault? Protect Yourself with Legal Help 📢
2. “I’m Not Hurt” or “I Feel Fine”
Right after a crash, you might not feel pain due to adrenaline. But that doesn’t mean you’re uninjured. Symptoms of whiplash, back injuries, or concussions may not appear for hours—or even days.
Why this is a problem:
✔ Saying you’re “fine” can be used to discredit your injury claim later on.
✔ Insurance companies may refuse to pay for medical treatment that arises after your statement.
✅ What to say instead: “I’m going to get checked out by a doctor to make sure I’m okay.”
📢 Delayed Injury Symptoms? Find Out If You Can Still File 📢
3. “I Think…” or “I Guess…”
Avoid speculating about what happened, who caused the accident, or how fast anyone was going. You might feel pressured to answer quickly, but giving vague or uncertain answers can backfire.
Why this is a problem:
✔ Guessing can cause inconsistencies in your story, weakening your credibility.
✔ Your statement may contradict other evidence like the police report or witness testimony.
✅ What to say instead: “I don’t want to speculate. I’d prefer to provide a statement after I review the facts and speak with my lawyer.”
4. “Sure, You Can Record Me”
Adjusters often ask if they can record your statement. You are not legally required to agree, and in most cases, you should decline—especially if you don’t have legal representation.
Why this is a problem:
✔ A recorded statement can be used against you even if you misspeak or forget details.
✔ Insurance adjusters are trained to ask leading questions that produce damaging soundbites.
✅ What to say instead: “I’m not comfortable being recorded at this time. I’d like to consult with an attorney first.”
📢 Don’t Let a Recorded Statement Cost You Your Claim 📢
5. “I’ll Take the Offer” (Before Reviewing Everything)
Insurance companies often try to settle quickly. They may make an offer before you’ve had time to:
See a doctor
Assess long-term costs
Get a second opinion
Why this is a problem:
✔ Accepting an early offer typically requires signing a release of liability, preventing you from seeking additional compensation—even if injuries worsen.
✔ The first offer is almost always far below what your claim is worth.
✅ What to say instead: “I’ll need time to review this offer with my attorney before making any decisions.”
📢 Think You’re Being Lowballed? Get a Free Review 📢
Bonus Tips: How to Talk to an Insurance Adjuster Safely
Stick to the basic facts (time, location, vehicles involved).
Don’t offer opinions or estimates.
Take notes on everything discussed during the call.
Avoid posting about the accident on social media.
🚨 REMEMBER: You can (and should) politely decline to speak with the adjuster until you’ve spoken with an attorney.
When to Contact a Lawyer
You should reach out to a lawyer immediately if:
You suffered any kind of injury
The police report places you at fault
The insurance company is pressuring you to settle
Your vehicle is totaled or requires major repairs
The other driver is uninsured or underinsured
An experienced personal injury attorney will:
Handle all communication with insurance companies
Ensure your rights are protected
Fight for the compensation you truly deserve
📢 Get a Free Case Evaluation with a Legal Expert Now 📢
Final Thoughts: Protect Your Claim by Choosing Your Words Wisely
Dealing with insurance adjusters after an accident is tricky. What you say (and what you don’t say) can have a lasting impact on your claim. Avoid making these common mistakes, and always speak with a legal expert before providing a statement.
🚗 Key Takeaways:
Don’t downplay injuries
Don’t accept a quick offer without legal advice
Your words matter—make sure they’re working in your favor.
📢 Protect Your Rights Today – Get a Free Case Evaluation 📢
“What Not to Say to an Insurance Adjuster After a Car Accident“
